Please find below another installment in our popular regular series of frequently asked questions about immigration law. Although most of these questions have come from real clients of Spar & Bernstein, we have also included questions from other resources for your benefit. Please note that the answers here are to be used for guideline purposes only, as the questions are specific to a particular case and may not necessarily be the best advice for YOUR situation.
*****
Question: I am on F-1/J-1 visa (student visa). Can I apply for green card (Permanent Residency)?
Answer: There is no law that prohibits an F-1, J-1, F-2, or J-2 visa holder from applying for a green card directly. But as a practical matter it takes a long time to obtain a green card in most cases. Therefore, even if you begin your green card process while you are on F or J status you will probably be required to convert to H-1 due to lack of time. Conversion to H-1 during green card pendency is no problem.
*****
Question: The following discussion applies to all visas where working is not permitted. Most typical examples of these types of visas are F-2 and H-4. The question often arises whether or not it is legal for such folks to volunteer their time or are they constrained to stay at home.
Answer: Probably yes. The provisions of law noted below are vague and unclear. But it appears as long as you do not receive any money or other remuneration, you should not be considered to be violating any laws. If you do receive any “in kind” benefits, things get very tricky. Such benefits may be permitted if the H-4/F-2 holder did not ask for the benefits as a condition for volunteering, nor were they offered in exchange for the volunteer work, and if the volunteer would have performed the services regardless of whether he or she were to receive the in-kind benefits. Subsection (f) below defines “employee” as someone who works for an “employer” for “wages or other remuneration.
*****
Question: I am a doctor from Pakistan and I had got a residency in internal medicine last year. I got my H1-B visa stamped but couldn’t go to USA because of some reasons. So the hospital got my H1-B visa legally cancelled. This year again I have got residency in another hospital and they are ready to sponsor my H1-B visa. I wanted to ask you if there be any problem from USCIS in processing my petition this time as my visa got cancelled last year. As I have not told this hospital about my visa cancellation last year will that be a problem. Will my petition be processed in a routine way this time too by USCIS?
Answer: It looks like your visa was not cancelled; you just did not use it. Note two things. First, non-use of an earlier issued visa should not create any problems in the future. But second and much more important, you HAVE to tell the hospital that you had an H-1 earlier. As far as I know, there is a question on the H-1 forms that specifically asks that question. Not answering the questions on the forms truthfully can get you into trouble. Check the forms, if there is no question that asks about any earlier H-1, you are fine.
